Finding a decent GeSHi plugin for WordPress

I like GeSHi (enough even to have written a language file for it). For ages now, I’ve used a WordPress plugin by Dan Peverill. But for as long as I’ve been using the plugin, I’ve been looking to get rid of it.

Dan Peverill’s GeSHI plugin sucks for two reasons:

1. It’s no longer being maintained. It doesn’t even seem to justify a page on Dan’s website anymore (for which reason I’m not going to give him any link-juice).
2. It breaks HTML. With the plugin enabled I can no longer use the <code> tag to mark in-line elements as being code. Frankly, this is annoying and I find myself typing <tt> often when I mean <code>.

A search for WordPress plugins tagged GeSHi reveals a number of results: Sniplets, CodeColorer, Developer Formatter, and WP-SynHighlight. WP-Syntax is a plugin that is missing from the tag search.

Sniplets seems much too generic to my taste. I just want a GeSHi highlighter, period.

CodeColorer says it does what I want, but if I ever want to use the TinyMCE editor again, I won’t be able to with this plugin. Shouldn’t be too much of a problem, but still…

Developer Formatter is very thoroughly written and even sports a TinyMCE plug-in for copying/pasting the code. It is pretty big, though, and, as a rule, I tend to avoid plug-ins that complicate the database schema. I also don’t really see how these extra tables are an advantage feature-wise.

WP-SynHighlight uses a custom BBCode-style tag, [codesyntax] I like this (if you’re going to use pointy brackets, at least keep out of the HTML namespace), though I don’t like the attempt at a generic name; what’s wrong with calling the tag [geshi]? Seriously… I’m sure I’m going to forget this name billions of times if I’ll use this plug-in.

WP-Syntax uses the <pre> tag with a few custom attributes. This at least is better than the officially inline <code> tag that my current plugin uses, because most of the time that I’d use a <pre> tag I really do want syntax highlighting. Just wondering: will it also allow my to use it normally for that other rare occasion? Sadly, the plugin will doubtlessly wreak havoc with the visual (TinyMCE) editor.

So, which plugin will I choose? I am somehow inclined to want a plugin that can play nice with the visual editor because I keep telling myself how much nicer it would be to switch to the visual editor for all my posting. (That this will be difficult because I disabled WP’s ‘wpautop‘ filter to rid myself of its eagerness is a story for some later time.) This requirement rules out CodeColorer and WP-Syntax.

That leaves Developer Formatter and WP-SynHighlight. Both seem to fit my purpose. Developer Formatter sports a nice TinyMCE plugin for inserting code, but I don’t think that switching to TinyMCE will suddenly and unexpectedly make me afraid of typing. Besides, I really don’t want the extra tables in my database without a very good reason, so, for now, I will try WP-SynHighlight.