Dan Peverill’s GeSHI plugin sucks for two reasons:

1. It’s no longer being maintained. It doesn’t even seem to justify a page on Dan’s website anymore (for which reason I’m not going to give him any link-juice).
2. It breaks HTML. With the plugin enabled I can no longer use the <code> tag to mark in-line elements as being code. Frankly, this is annoying and I find myself typing <tt> often when I mean <code>.

A search for WordPress plugins tagged GeSHi reveals a number of results: Sniplets, CodeColorer, Developer Formatter, and WP-SynHighlight. WP-Syntax is a plugin that is missing from the tag search.

Sniplets seems much too generic to my taste. I just want a GeSHi highlighter, period.

CodeColorer says it does what I want, but if I ever want to use the TinyMCE editor again, I won’t be able to with this plugin. Shouldn’t be too much of a problem, but still…

Developer Formatter is very thoroughly written and even sports a TinyMCE plug-in for copying/pasting the code. It is pretty big, though, and, as a rule, I tend to avoid plug-ins that complicate the database schema. I also don’t really see how these extra tables are an advantage feature-wise.

WP-SynHighlight uses a custom BBCode-style tag, [codesyntax] I like this (if you’re going to use pointy brackets, at least keep out of the HTML namespace), though I don’t like the attempt at a generic name; what’s wrong with calling the tag [geshi]? Seriously… I’m sure I’m going to forget this name billions of times if I’ll use this plug-in.

WP-Syntax uses the <pre> tag with a few custom attributes. This at least is better than the officially inline <code> tag that my current plugin uses, because most of the time that I’d use a <pre> tag I really do want syntax highlighting. Just wondering: will it also allow my to use it normally for that other rare occasion? Sadly, the plugin will doubtlessly wreak havoc with the visual (TinyMCE) editor.

So, which plugin will I choose? I am somehow inclined to want a plugin that can play nice with the visual editor because I keep telling myself how much nicer it would be to switch to the visual editor for all my posting. (That this will be difficult because I disabled WP’s ‘wpautop‘ filter to rid myself of its eagerness is a story for some later time.) This requirement rules out CodeColorer and WP-Syntax.

That leaves Developer Formatter and WP-SynHighlight. Both seem to fit my purpose. Developer Formatter sports a nice TinyMCE plugin for inserting code, but I don’t think that switching to TinyMCE will suddenly and unexpectedly make me afraid of typing. Besides, I really don’t want the extra tables in my database without a very good reason, so, for now, I will try WP-SynHighlight.